What is Casting and Forging: Pros, Cons, & Applications
Casting and forging are techniques used for shaping metal into intricate components. Learn about their differences, pros and cons, and common applications.
Casting and forging are both key metalworking techniques used to shape materials into components. However, due to their varying processes, the resulting properties of forged and cast metal products differ significantly.
This article will outline the differences between forged metal vs cast metal, by discussing their production processes, pros, and cons, allowing you to make informed decisions in your specific application.
Casting: Process, Strengths, and Weaknesses
What is Casting?
Casting involves melting metal before pouring it into a mold or die. The molten metal is then allowed to cool and solidify, taking on the shape of the mold to form the final product.
Casting techniques can be further categorized by molding materials, filling pressure, and specific production steps. Common techniques include sand casting which uses a mold made from sand, high-pressure die casting (HPDC) which rapidly fills the mold through high-pressure injection, gravity die casting which allows the molten metal to gradually flow into the mold, and investment casting (lost wax casting) which requires creating a master pattern out of wax.
For a more in-depth look at these different casting techniques, you can refer to our article:
➤ What Are The Different Types of Die Casting Processes?
Image Source: Freepik
Advantages of Casting
One of the primary benefits of casting is its ability to produce complex shapes with high consistency. With molten metal and precise molds, manufacturers can accurately replicate intricate components of various sizes and weights, offering versatility in part design.
Another significant advantage of casting is its flexible production volume, as you can choose a manufacturing technique by balancing its turnaround time and design accuracy. For instance, an efficient technique like high-pressure die casting is especially ideal for mass-producing identical parts.
Additionally, casting often results in metal parts with superior metallurgical characteristics. This is because it can accommodate a wide range of alloy materials to achieve specific properties based on your needs. The cooling process involved in casting also helps to minimize porosity and improve the final product’s texture.
The improved surface texture and properties of cast metal can further minimize the need for extensive machining or other finishing operations. This reduces the overall labor requirements, making casting a cost-effective manufacturing process.
Limitations of Casting
There is a potential for defects in casting. If the molten metal is subjected to uneven cooling rates during the solidifying process, it could lead to stresses within the material, resulting in internal tears or cracks on the final product.
Moreover, the liquid metal may have a risk of contamination by impurities like gases or other foreign materials before it solidifies. This could negatively affect the final product, leading to undesirable outcomes in terms of mechanical strength, durability, corrosion resistance, or other properties.
To minimize the risk of these issues, it is best to work with trusted manufacturers that practice rigorous quality assurance measures. For example, X-ray inspections can help to identify defects and ensure the integrity of the cast components, while techniques like stress-relief annealing or baking can remove metal impurities, ensuring the final product’s quality before it is shipped to you.
Forging: Process, Strengths, and Weaknesses
What is Forging?
In forging, a piece of a piece of metal, typically in the form of a billet or ingot, is heated to a specific temperature to make it malleable. It is then shaped into the desired form with mechanical force using tools like hammers, presses, or dies.
Forging techniques can be categorized based on the manufacturing temperature, either as hot forging, warm forging, or cold forging. They can also be differentiated depending on the die configuration. For example, there is a method called open-die forging which relies on striking the metal on a stationary anvil to manipulate the metal’s shape, whereas the other method, closed-die forging, requires the heated metal to be encased between dies to form the design.
Image Source: Freepik
Advantages of Forging
Forging offers metal components with greater strength and durability. The grain structure of the metal will be aligned in the process, eliminating voids to create a denser product. In turn, this contributes to increased strength, durability, and resistance to wear and tear.
In addition, forged metal components have a reduced likelihood of defects like cracks or shrinkage, as the material stays solid throughout the process while being compressed, refining its microstructure for a more homogeneous result.
Furthermore, forging requires less tooling and materials, so it may have a lower operational cost. Reduced material waste can also contribute to further savings, making forging a budget-friendly option for medium to high-volume production.
Limitations of Forging
Forging relies more on additional finishing processes, like machining or grinding, to achieve the desired surface finish. This is particularly prevalent in hot forging where extremely high temperatures can cause surface oxidation and scaling.
Another limitation of forging is the complexity of shapes that can be produced. While forging is well-suited for simple shapes, creating intricate and complex geometries can be challenging, as the tooling required for such shapes can be expensive and time-consuming to design and manufacture.
Plus, the material options for forging are limited as well. As the material stays solid throughout the entire process, less malleable alloys may be difficult or impossible to forge. Hence, you may have to consider alternative techniques to manufacture such materials.
Metal Casting vs Forging: Which is the One for You?
To sum up, casting pours molten metal into molds with the desired forms before leaving it to solidify, whereas forging shapes heated solid metal using mechanical force. They are both great metalworking processes but suited for different applications.
So when you are choosing between casting and forging, you must consider the part design, material options, desired properties, surface finish, and budget. To help you with this decision, here is a table summarizing the key differences between casting and forging for your reference:
| Technique | Casting | Forging |
|---|---|---|
| Design Complexity | Able to create complex geometries and intricate details | More suitable for parts with simple geometries and design |
| Part Size | Depends on the specific method, small parts are as thin as 0.5mm and large parts can have surface areas of up to 1,290cm². | Small parts less than a centimeter, to large parts weighing up to 320,000 kg, but the larger the part, the harder it is to forge |
| Material Options | Versatile with various metals like cast iron, steel, aluminum, copper alloys, magnesium alloys, zinc alloys, etc. | Mainly carbon steels, alloy steels, aluminum, titanium, and high-temperature materials like nickel-based, cobalt-based, and iron-based alloys |
| Product Properties | Relatively less strength but properties can be specified with alloy combinations | Greater strength, durability, and resistance to wear and tear |
| Product Defect Risks | Susceptible to defects during the cooling process; requires quality assurance measures | Less susceptible to defects as the material stays solid throughout the process |
| Surface Finish | Good surface finish from the initial process | Requires additional finishing processes for desired surface finish |
| Cost | Generally cost-effective but depends on the specific casting method | Lower operational costs, usually more cost-effective for medium to high-volume productions |
Industries that Leverage Forged vs Cast Products
Industries with Casted Metal Products
Image Source: Freepik
Due to its ability to create intricate designs with high accuracy, casting is commonly used in industries such as:
Automotive: The automotive industry leverages casting to produce engine blocks, cylinder heads, transmission housings, brake calipers, and other components, as the design accuracy helps ensure the reliability and safety of vehicles.
Plumbing and HVAC: Metal casting can be used to create components such as valves, fittings, radiators, and heat exchangers for precise flow control in plumbing or ventilation systems.
Consumer Goods: With metal casting, manufacturers can make cookware, lighting fixtures, toys, and various other consumer goods. Not only can this improve the quality of these products, but it can also contribute to their design aesthetics.
Telecommunications: This industry relies on casting to manufacture components like enclosure panels and heat sinks, ensuring the functionality and durability of critical networking equipment
Industries with Forged Metal Products
Image Source: Freepik
Forging is ideal for applications that require high component strength and durability, including:
Industrial Machinery: With forged metal, industrial machinery components such as gearboxes, crankshafts, and connecting rods can provide the required reliability for demanding applications without the risk of damage from mechanical stress.
Oil and Gas: Oil and gas systems often involve high pressure and temperature. With forging, manufacturers can create valves, flanges, pump shafts, and other critical components that can withstand these extreme conditions.
Construction: This industry utilizes forged metal for various applications, including structural components, bridge fittings, and heavy machinery parts to ensure the long-lasting integrity of building structures.
Best Casting and Forging Solutions at Teamsworld
In conclusion, casting and forging are essential metalworking processes that offer unique advantages and limitations respectively. By understanding their differences, you can select the most suitable method to produce components for your projects.
As a leading casting and forging company, Teamsworld specializes in providing high-quality metal parts. With over 30 years of experience and state-of-the-art facilities, we deliver precision-engineered solutions that meet the highest industry standards, as certified by ISO 9001:2015 and IATF 16949.
We are also committed to upholding sustainable practices as a B-Corp-certified manufacturer, leveraging our cloud-based platform to streamline project management and reduce our carbon footprint.
By choosing Teamsworld, you're choosing a partner that delivers excellence. Our skilled team will work closely with you to understand your specific needs and create tailored services at every step of the manufacturing process, from design conceptualization to delivery. Contact Teamsworld today for a free consultation and bring your product vision to life!